Sebi’s nod to retail algo trading levels the playing field with institutions

Open for public feedback until 3 January 2025, the proposal emphasizes inclusivity while reinforcing market integrity through stringent safeguards.

Decoding the proposal

Sebi’s draft framework outlines key measures to make algo trading accessible yet accountable. Retail investors will be able to participate through brokers, who must obtain exchange approvals for each algorithm before deployment. Each algorithm will be assigned a unique identifier for effective monitoring and auditing. To enhance security, brokers are required to implement robust application programming interfaces (APIs) with two-factor authentication, ensuring system integrity and preventing unauthorized access.

Additionally, tech-savvy retail investors can register self-developed algorithms via brokers for personal or family trading. Sebi has also classified algorithms into two types: “white box” (transparent logic) and “black box” (undisclosed logic). Black box algorithms face stricter norms, including mandatory registration of algo providers as research analysts and detailed reporting of strategies.

Levelling the playing field

The framework represents a major step in democratizing India’s capital markets by equipping retail investors with tools previously exclusive to institutions. Algorithmic trading’s ability to execute trades in milliseconds based on pre-programmed logic allows retail investors to overcome time lags inherent in manual decision-making.

Read this | How will AI help democratise intelligence in algorithmic trading? Here are 5 ways

For example, algorithms can track market variables like price movements, trading volumes, and global trends in real time, executing trades automatically when specific conditions are met. This ensures timely action, a critical advantage in fast-paced markets.

Market expert Sunil Subramaniam points out that institutional investors have long leveraged algo trading to react swiftly to macroeconomic events such as the US Federal Reserve policy changes or inflation data. Extending these capabilities to retail investors enables them to seize opportunities and manage risks effectively, even when they are not actively monitoring the market.

Beyond speed, algorithms can automate strategies like stop-loss orders and profit booking, ensuring disciplined risk management. By bridging the gap in time-to-action, Sebi’s framework empowers retail investors to respond to market dynamics with precision, creating a more level playing field in an increasingly competitive environment.

Market integrity: The cornerstone

A key focus of Sebi’s proposal is market integrity, aimed at preventing misuse of algorithms for market manipulation or other systemic risks. The use of unique identifiers ensures traceability, while rigorous approval processes reduce the chances of reckless algo deployment.

Sebi’s stricter controls on black box algorithms minimize opacity, protecting the market from disruptions caused by rogue strategies. Stock exchanges are tasked with overseeing implementation and ensuring compliance, while “kill switches” are proposed to halt trades from malfunctioning algorithms—adding an extra layer of security. Together, these measures aim to foster trust and stability in India’s capital markets.

A global perspective

India’s cautious approach to regulating algo trading contrasts with the relatively lighter touch seen in developed markets. In the US, regulations emphasize post-trade transparency and penalties for misuse but have faced challenges, such as the 2010 Flash Crash, which exposed the systemic risks of poorly monitored algorithms. Reforms in the US introduced measures like circuit breakers to curb market disruptions.

Similarly, Europe’s Markets in Financial Instruments Directive II (MiFID II) mandates pre-trade controls, kill switches, and robust risk management systems for firms engaging in algo trading. 

Read this | The bravado of retail investors: Buying the dip or skating on thin ice?

Sebi’s focus on approval-based deployment and unique identifiers reflects a deliberate approach to prioritize stability. If successfully implemented, this framework could become a model for other emerging markets looking to democratize algo trading while maintaining systemic integrity.

Conclusion

Sebi’s initiative to extend algo trading to retail investors marks a transformative moment in India’s financial markets. By prioritizing transparency, accountability, and innovation, the framework seeks to empower retail investors without compromising market stability.

Also read | What Sebi’s taming of algo trading means for the market

The success of this initiative will hinge on its effective implementation and the collaboration of brokers, exchanges, and investors. If executed well, Sebi’s proposal could not only level the playing field but also strengthen trust and stability in India’s capital markets, fostering a more inclusive and efficient trading ecosystem.

Simarjeet Singh is Assistant Professor (Accounting and Finance) at Great Lakes Institute of Management, Gurgaon. Views expressed are personal.